Publication of award-TC1

By TCN PMU,

  Filed under: Breaking News, Expression of Interest (EOI), Featured Projects, Latest News
  Comments: None


TRANSMISSION COMPANY NIGERIA (TCN)

Project Management Unit (PMU)

Contracts Awarded by QCBS

 

Name of Project: Nigeria Electricity Transmission Project (NETAP)

Project ID:  61850-NG

Bid/Contract Description: QCBS-NTP-TC1

Scope of Contract:  Technical Assistance for Engineering Supervision and Site Management of Rehabilitation and Reinforcement of 330/132kV & 132/33kV Transmission Substations (Package 1)

 

Duration: 24Months   Contract Signature Date: Not Yet Signed

 

 

Awarded Bidder

Name & Address* of awarded bidder

Bid price at bid opening

Final bid price

GOPA-INTERNATIONAL ENERGY CONSULTANTS GmbH, GERMANY

 

GOPA-International Energy Consultants GmBH (intec) Justus-von-Liebig-Str. 1, 61352 Bad Homburg, Germany

EURO 1,770,034.00

NGN 94,730,804.06

EURO 2,061,098.15

NGN 104,203,884.47

 

 

 

Evaluated Bidder(s)

Name of evaluated bidder(s)

Bid price at bid opening

Bid price of evaluated bid

Ranking for Combined score of  Tech. & Fin

GOPA-INTERNATIONAL ENERGY CONSULTANTS GmbH, GERMANY

EURO 1,770,034.00

NGN 94,730,804.06

EURO 2,061,098.15

NGN 104,203,884.47

1st

JV of TRACTEBEL/COYNE & BELLIER/ OTIS CONSULTING ENGNEERS NIGERIA LTD

US$2,545,770.00

NGN896,017,287.00

US$2,545,770.00

NGN896,017,287.00

2nd

 

 

 

 

Rejected Bidder(s)

Name of rejected bidder(s)

Bid price at bid opening

Reason(s) for rejection

WAPCOS LIMITED, INDIA

Financial Proposal was not opened

The firm scored below the minimum mark in their Technical Proposal. The Financial proposal of WAPCOS Limited will be returned unopened after contract award.

BYUCKSAN POWER Co. Ltd

Financial Proposal was not opened

Contrary to Clause 12.3 of Section 2 (Instructions to Consultants) of the issued RFP, BYUCKSAN Power Co., Ltd, presented curriculum vitae for the following five key experts that were not confirmed/endorsed by the proposed experts

· Project Manager.

· Substation Specialist.

· SCADA Specialist.

· 5th Site Electrical Engineer.

· 4th Civil Engineer.

Based on the above Clause 12.3 of the issued RFP, therefore, the firm’s proposal is disqualified and rejected from further evaluation.

CTSI OIL & GAS PROJECTS NIGERIA LIMITED

 

Financial Proposal was not opened

The Memorandum of Understanding in the proposal submitted by CTSI Oil & Gas Projects Nigeria Ltd (as RINA CTSI Nigeria Ltd) shows that the firm is in a joint venture (JV) with RINA Consulting Limited (United Kingdom) being the lead consultant, RINA CTSI Nigeria Ltd being a JV Partner and RITINGER being a sub-contractor. However, the RFP was issued to only CTSI Oil & Gas Projects Nigeria Ltd being the prequalified firm as approved by the World Bank. There is no evidence to show that the shortlisted CTSI Oil & Gas Projects Nigeria Ltd obtained a written approval of the Client before submitting the proposal as a JV. This is contrary to Clause 14.1.1 of Section 2 - Instruction to Consultants (ITC) of the issued RFP.

 

Also, contrary to Clause 12.3 of Section 2 (ITC) of the issued RFP, the curriculum vitae presented by RINA CTSI Nigeria Limited for the Project Manager and the SCADA Specialist were both endorsed/confirmed by the same person.

 

Based on the above Clauses 14.1.1 and 12.3 of the issued RFP, the proposal from the JV of RINA Consulting (United Kingdom), RINA CTSI Nigeria Limited and RITINGER is considered non – responsive to the RFP and will not be further evaluated.

TATA CONSULTING ENGINEERS LIMITED (INDIA)

 

 

The Proposal was submitted by the JV of TATA Consulting Engineers Limited and MOSRA Energy Limited instead of only TATA Consulting Engineers Limited being the prequalified firm as approved by the World Bank.  The Memorandum of Understanding in the proposal submitted by TATA Consulting Engineers Limited (India) shows that the company is the lead partner in a joint venture (JV) with MOSRA Energy Limited. However, there is no evidence to show that TATA Consulting Engineers Limited (India) obtained a written approval of the Client before submitting the proposal as a JV. This is contrary to Clause 14.1.1 of Section 2 (ITC) of the issued RFP.

 

Based on the above reasons therefore, their proposal is disqualified and rejected from further evaluation.

 

ADDRESS

Transmission Company of Nigeria – Project Management Unit (TCN-PMU)

 

Engr. Dahiru A. I. - Project Manager (WBP)

No. 10, Kunene Close, Off Bobo Street,

Off Gana Street, Maitama District,

Abuja 900271,

NIGERIA

Tel: +234 8080288802 or +234 8080288803  

E-mail: tcnpmu@tcnpmu.ng & dahiru.isyaku@tcn.org.ng  

Website: www.tcnpmu.ng

 

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Notify of
avatar

wpDiscuz